The Non-fat, High Carbohydrate Diet Fantasy

Julia was a lovely patient who was desperate to lose 125 lbs. I had asked her to keep a food diary for a few weeks. A food diary allowed me to view eating habits and nutrient consumption.  Honesty is the best policy here or you’re only hurting yourself. Remember, just like salvation, Truth is Absolute.

th41IT1JJDI noticed she had listed six cookies as one snack. I asked her why, and she sighed, “But Ellie, they’re fat-free!”

Unfortunately, fat free doesn’t mean calorie free and if you consume more calories than your metabolism burns off, you’ll still gain weight.  Cookies are fine once in a while in moderation, just select one that contain nutrients; such as fig newtons, oatmeal raisin, macadamia nut or even dark chocolate cookies.  What’s my mantra?  “Eat for nutrients!” We need balance to stay healthy. Skip a vital nutrient and we become unbalanced, mentally and physically! Don’t believe hype!

 “Do not be led away by diverse and strange teachings, for it is good for the heart to be strengthened by grace, not by foods, which have not benefited those devoted to them.” (Hebrews 13:9)

The Dangers of A Non-Fat Diet  (basically an extremely low (10-15%) or fat-free diet, with little added protein.)

  • Without fat, the body breaks down muscle tissue to use as protein for energy. “Danger, Danger Will Robinson!!” THE HEART IS A MUSCLE! Heart disease and lower HDL protective cholesterol is a distinct possibility!
  • Everyone has something called brown fat which cushions and insulates our vital organs. Born with all the brown fat we’ll get, it generates heat and regulates metabolism. It’s never reproduced through food intake but is lost on low-fat diets.
  • A fat-free diet increases insulin production, upping the chances of diabetes, anxiety attacks, depression and personality changes.
  • Carb dieters seem to forget the “simple versus complex” carb difference. Complex carbs offer vital fiber, vitamins and mineral nutrients found in fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. Simple carbs are usually processed goodies such as donuts, candy, cookies and other sugary foods without substantial nutrients.
  • Many dieters then use artificial sugars. Sugar has only 16 calories per teaspoon and there are no artificial chemicals in sugar. Use real sugar for your coffee or baking, just use less of it. Note: I’ll have a blog on the dangers of Splenda soon.
  • Dieters have a mentality of “if it’s-fat free, I can eat more of it” and will lose sight of self-discipline.
  • Non-fat processed foods usually increase sodium for added flavor which raises blood pressure.

Basic Benefits of Fat:

  • Fat is a necessary component for transport of vitamins A, D, E and K throughout your system.
  • Most adults need 44 to 78 grams (11-19 tsp or 2/3 to 1 cup) of good fat per day. Remember, 4 grams = one teaspoon. 3 tsp. = 1 tablespoon = 120 pure fat calories. (Visualize 20-50% of a piece of meat as fat) A little goes a long way. Keep nuts, avocados, olives, flaxseed, tuna, salmon, olive, canola oil, and other good fats loaded with nutrients, in your diet.
  • Cutting out fat is crazy!  Our skin would look sallow, we’ll get colder, have little energy, our hair would lose its luster and even fall out.
  • Without fat, you’ll feel unsatisfied and your brain will nag for any fat until you give in to a greasy burger or bacon.

As for me and my house, I’ll listen to my God as he told Noah in Genesis 9:3, “Every moving thing that lives shall be food for you. And as I gave you the green plants, I give you everything.” and not to false diet gurus who say what our “tickling ears” want to hear.


8 thoughts on “The Non-fat, High Carbohydrate Diet Fantasy

  1. I’ve been trying to lose weight for a while now, and even when I eat healthy (veggies, organic, protein, whole grains, and watch ingredients) I still don’t lose. I just had a physical, and my doctor said it was the carbs: I needed to cut down on carbs and eat more protein and fat. Now that I have your confirmation, guess I better get to it :-). Thank you for sharing!


    • Thank you Mary, I always appreciate hearing comments. God in His Infinite Wisdom created us all with a unique chemistry make-up. Individuals metabolize fats, protein and carbohydrates differently. What works for one might not for another. We should eat healthily because we want to honor our Lord.

      Important: Did your doctor distinguish between simple and complex carbs??? Do you already know the difference? We need more water-based fruits, vegetables and fibrous foods to lose weight, not simple carbs like donuts, cakes, pies and high sugar foods. Simple carbs raise our insulin levels and creates hunger. In moderation they are a real treat but shouldn’t rule your diet plan. Please use my search engine above and you’ll find many posts regarding carbohydrates.

      Sidenote: There were two diet studies completed recently. One group went on a strict low-calorie plan and the other ate normally but simply increased their fiber foods. Each lost the same amount of weight but one suffered and one group didn’t. Eat for Nutrients and don’t suffer. If I can assist you in any other way please ask. Blessings for success!


Have a question or comment? I'd really enjoy hearing from you,

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s