Why I’m Wary of the Glycemic Index

thEN89HMNTThe Glycemic Index was created in 1980 by the world-famous professor and physician, Dr. David J. Jenkins.  This graphed theory apparently shows how long it takes carbohydrates to break down into sugar.  His good intentions and clinical research has assisted many diabetics in regulating their blood sugar challenges.

But there was always something that made me uneasy about endorsing his findings and recommending this to my patients. I had too many questions. Why were all rice, cereals and breads lumped into one category? How could a nutrient-dense potato be as detrimental as a pastry with none? Raisin Bran is certainly better than Cornflakes and I don’t consider whole grain bread on par with enriched white. Nevertheless, unless the results have been ratified into more defined categories over the years, they were considered  on the same level.

This fact wouldn’t actually make me more at ease because man’s ideas have always changed over time, but my God Never Changes. God’s Knowledge trumps man’s knowledge every time. I trust God.  Each one of us is uniquely God designed. The glycemic index is intended to put each of us in a box. Well, sometimes a square peg can’t fit into a round hole no matter how diligently man tries to redesign it!

Regarding their clinical studies; I wanted to know how many participants were athletes as opposed to couch potatoes? What % of body fat were they? (muscle burns sugar) What was eaten before they attempted the test? How many hours before? (Carbohydrates remain in your system for 2-3 hours while protein stays for 4-5 and fat for 7 hours.) How did lifestyles factor into the tests? Each person has different daily stresses which affects our chemical make-up. Were some participants under family or work stress? Stress raises insulin with it’s “fight or flight” effect.

What about the fiber content of foods? I didn’t see where the glycemic index took that into consideration. Fiber allows insulin to be released more slowly into bodily systems so there are fewer blood sugar spikes. If one is following a low glycemic index, definite instructions must come with it! Long grain rice is more fibrous than quick cooking rice. I, along with the American Diabetic Association, recommends high fiber foods such as whole grains, beans, legumes while cutting down on unhealthy fats. According to the glycemic index however, one can head to Pizza Hut, consume half a pizza and then head to Ben and Jerry’s for some low glycemic ice cream. Whoopee, I like that diet!

Consuming LESS fibrous foods allows the body to release its water storage. Yes, one will lose weight.  Not consuming carbs means less water weight, but it’s a mirage. Fiber attracts water to help with its digestive tract. As soon as you consume fiber, your body will absorb water naturally, but you’ll believe carbohydrates are the culprit.

Here’s another reason: Processed foods with all its artificial chemical ingredients are lumped alongside pumpkin with all its nutrients. Pumpkin contains vitamins A, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, C, E, K, calcium, iron, potassium, manganese, magnesium, phosphorous, zinc, copper, plus amino acids and more! How could they be equal?

To me the glycemic index doesn’t add up. So what other would I recommend? What’s my mantra again? Eat for nutrients:  Whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, herbs and lean protein will provide a healthy, balanced, joyful God-enriched life! (Genesis 1:29 & 9:3)


“But I would feed you with the finest of the wheat, And with honey from the rock I would satisfy you.” Psalm 81:16






14 thoughts on “Why I’m Wary of the Glycemic Index

  1. I have been finding great healing and peace in doing things God’s way. I completely agree with you, Ellie. I am thankful that He created each of us to be unique and that His Word shows us how to live a healthy and abundant life for Him and His glory.


  2. Well said. I get frustrated that snacks (Nature Valley granola bars and such) I used to trust are now sugary with icing, and other useless calories. Energy drinks are another “baddy.” I’ll stop here or I would rave all night. sd


  3. wow thanks for this !!! , you also got a new follower – who is also a sister in Christ and willing to lose weight (i quit smoking a while ago and i got – erm … nicely rounded … sigh 🙂 )


  4. Ellie, my doctor gave me a handout (written in doctor language) to help me with my “chronic inflammation” . The paper says I should eat an “anti-inflammation diet, essential fatty acids, and other anti-inflammatory supplements.” Can you translate?!


    • Hi my friend! Sorry that your doctor didn’t clarify what that means to you in dog years, as I say. Never fear, it’s not complicated and it is what I have been advocating all along. Hope you are still consuming water and your children are involved too! Inflammation can lead to some health problems later on so please take this seriously.

      Try to consume mostly antioxidant, alkaline foods: fruits, vegetables like broccoli, spinach, leafy greens, sweet potatoes, beans, and anything else that was in the Garden of Eden. Cut down on wheat (which is more acidic) for awhile and consume oats, quinoa, long grain rice, whole grain pastas more often. Lean protein like fish, chicken or lean pork or beef (loin) for awhile.

      Essential fatty acids are olive, canola oil, milled flaxseed, fatty fish like salmon. Get yourself some good quality yogurt and cut down on any dyes, preservatives and processed foods which are acidic.

      Find ways to alleviate your stress like exercising with your cute kids, going for a walk in the fresh air or water aerobics. I’ll try to write a blog about this for you so I can go into more detail. Would that work? You can always email me too, 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      • This helps me a lot. Thank you so much. I am also sure many people would benefit from a blog post too.

        I think cutting down on wheat will be really hard.


Have a question or comment? I'd really enjoy hearing from you,

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s